Reader Forums
Astronomy forums are FREE. If you wish to participate you must LOGIN | REGISTER.

General astronomy discussion

The Moon moving away from the Earth
Last post 03-27-2009 02:15 AM by chipdatajeffB. 13 replies.
Sort Posts:
Page 1 of 1 (14 items)
  • 09-14-2008 08:32 PM

    • leroy37
    • Joined on 04-25-2008
    • Texas
    • Posts 82

    The Moon moving away from the Earth

    OK as we all Know the moon is moving about 3.8 centimeters away from the earth per year . So my questions are... when the moon was formed around earth how close was it? Wouldnt the earths gravity of pulled it in since the moon would been so close... and what would would the moon look  if you were 2 billon years back?  Thanks For Reading

    Signature
    "The universe is like a safe to which there is a combination, but the combination is locked up in the safe."
  • 09-14-2008 10:26 PM In reply to

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    The current model for the Moon's origin holds that a planetary body about the size of Mars struck the Earth a glancing blow and the Moon coalesced from the bits of the impactor and Earth's crust that were thrown into orbit.

    Some bits that were in low Earth orbit fell back to Earth once the Moon grew large enough for orbital resonances to disrupt the ring of material that had not yet coalesced. Other bits were thrown outward by those same resonances, depending on how close the Moon passed to them.

    So, on the one hand you could say the Moon was practically in contact with the Earth (since it formed from Earth impact ejecta) and in the other you could say it was "much nearer" the Earth (without being able to specify a precise orbit). The move outward was quite likely nonlinear, being a much more rapid retreat early on. Models differ on the details, of course, depending on the density, mass, velocity, and trajectory of the impactor and the amount of material it ejected from the Earth.

    This all happened something like 4 billion years ago (4,000 million years to perhaps 4,500 million years).

    Analysis of lunar rocks returned by the Apollo missions shows some of them were of that same age (the highland samples ... the mare basalts tended to be much younger, about 3,180 million years), so the accretion of the Moon from the impact remnants occurred very rapidly, in geological terms.

    Between 3,000 million and 3,500 million years ago, the Late Heavy Bombardment created most of the larger impact craters we see on the Moon today (and triggered the massive lava flows we see as the lunar maria).

    Therefore, the appearance of the Moon 2,000 million years ago would have been pretty much as we see it today. Astronauts walking the surface of the Moon in that period, however, would have noticed a much less rounded appearance to the crater rims and impact ejecta blankets than is apparent today -- because "gardening" by micrometeorite bombardment (which continues today) would have had much less time to "weather" the lunar surface.

    Signature
    The universe is not only stranger than we imagine, it's stranger than we CAN imagine. --- JBS Haldane
  • 09-15-2008 08:26 PM In reply to

    • jodoak
    • Joined on 08-10-2008
    • Oakfield, New York
    • Posts 211

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    If the moon is moving away from the earth a minute amount each year, are the planets doing the same thing in moving away from the sun a small amount each year?

    Signature
    John O'Donnell

    Orion SkyQuest XT10 Classic
    25mm Standard Eyepiece
    10mm Standard Eyepiece
    17MM Orion Stratus Wide-Field
    8mm Orion Stratus Wide-Field
    TeleVue 2x Barlow
    Telrad

    Einstein said: 'The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.'
  • 09-16-2008 02:51 PM In reply to

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    jodoak:

    If the moon is moving away from the earth a minute amount each year, are the planets doing the same thing in moving away from the sun a small amount each year?

    Yes, but the reason is different from that for the Moon.  As the Sun loses mass due to the solar wind and the conversion of matter into energy, its gravitational force lessens and the orbital semi-major axis (average distance) of each planet slowly increases. 

    In the case of the Moon, that body's gravity creates an oceanic tidal bulge on the Earth which is dragged to a position slightly forward of the Moon due to friction.  The gravitational attraction on the Moon from that forward shifted tidal bulge accelerates the Moon into a wider orbit, which paradoxically slows it down.  The simplistic theoretical way of looking at it is to say that the tidal friction takes away angular momentum from the Earth’s rotation and “transfers” some of it to the Moon’s orbital angular momentum.

     

    Signature
    For astronomical graphics, including
    monthly wallpaper calendar, visit:
    CurtRenz.com/astronomical

    Curt Renz - "Centaur"
  • 09-16-2008 09:05 PM In reply to

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    Now THAT's a good answer: short, sweet, covers all the bases!

    Signature
    The universe is not only stranger than we imagine, it's stranger than we CAN imagine. --- JBS Haldane
  • 09-17-2008 04:56 PM In reply to

    • jodoak
    • Joined on 08-10-2008
    • Oakfield, New York
    • Posts 211

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    Ok, so think of this scenario then. Currently astronomers think that Venus might be an early Earth, or something close to that. Mars, may or may not have some kind of life, but it has lost a lot of its atmosphere and water.

    Could the planets have been closer to the sun long ago where Mars was more in line to our orbital path and Earth may have been closer like Venus is now. Maybe our orbital path is at an optimum distance fromt he Sun for life to flourish and now Mars is in an orbital path where it can't. In time Earth moves further away, or the Sun shrinks some, causing life to extingusih on this planet and Venus moves into a more optimal orbital path for life to begin.

    Is this something ever thought of?

    Signature
    John O'Donnell

    Orion SkyQuest XT10 Classic
    25mm Standard Eyepiece
    10mm Standard Eyepiece
    17MM Orion Stratus Wide-Field
    8mm Orion Stratus Wide-Field
    TeleVue 2x Barlow
    Telrad

    Einstein said: 'The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.'
  • 09-17-2008 05:13 PM In reply to

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    Good thinking.  But the amount by which the planets have been moving outward has not been great enough to suit your scenario.  At the same time the Sun has been slowly but continuously growing hotter.  The concern is that over the next billion years the increased heat from the Sun will extinguish all life on Earth, despite the Earth moving further from the Sun.  At that time Mars may be more hospitable to life than Earth.

    Signature
    For astronomical graphics, including
    monthly wallpaper calendar, visit:
    CurtRenz.com/astronomical

    Curt Renz - "Centaur"
  • 09-17-2008 05:43 PM In reply to

    • jodoak
    • Joined on 08-10-2008
    • Oakfield, New York
    • Posts 211

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    I may not have the astronomical education but I have an active imagination for an older guy.

    Signature
    John O'Donnell

    Orion SkyQuest XT10 Classic
    25mm Standard Eyepiece
    10mm Standard Eyepiece
    17MM Orion Stratus Wide-Field
    8mm Orion Stratus Wide-Field
    TeleVue 2x Barlow
    Telrad

    Einstein said: 'The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.'
  • 09-17-2008 05:54 PM In reply to

    • ajohnson
    • Joined on 05-14-2008
    • Riverside, CA
    • Posts 85

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    An additonal theory about the differences between Venus and earth that I've heard is:  Our moon stripped away part of our atmosphere allowing life to occur.  Venus doesn't have a moon and so that never happened.

    I've also heard a theory that Venus could once have been like Earth, but it's closer proximity to the Sun caused it's oceans to evaporate into its atmosphere, and the lighter hydrogen escaped leaving carbon dioxide.

    Oh, and one other consequence of the Earths motion being transferred to the moon: Our days will increase in length until one day is about 47 hours long

    Signature
    8" Coulter Optical Dob,
    4.5" Orion Starblast on (unfinished) roboscoped clone CG5 mount
    4.5"DS-2114 (on goto DS mount, soon to be looking for a new home),
    C-11A XLT on Atlas EQ-G mount
    Canon EOS 40d


  • 09-18-2008 05:24 PM In reply to

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    there was a really cool special on the history channel or discovery channel where they went into the various theories. i really enjoyed the 3d model that shows the mars impact idea. they think that after the initial impact the big mass broke off and then reinpacted the earth again. with the heavier materials going back onto earth and the lighter crust type material beign ejected again and forming  the moon. eventually gathering all the debri matieriali.

     check out the animation if you have a chance. surely its on the internet somewhere.

  • 11-20-2008 07:10 PM In reply to

    • zyh
    • Joined on 11-20-2008
    • Posts 19

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    The moon is moving away from Earth 

    Due to the tidal forces of weight [gravity] and the tangential component [vortex force] two parts, vortex force to the moon is of increasing angular momentum away from the Earth, this process of angular momentum conservation, therefore slowing down the Earth's rotation cycle. In recent years, some countries in the world after scientists and technical workers in-depth observation and research, found that the moon is gradually away from us, and will be increasingly dark. The United States and France scientists use astronauts landing on the moon in 1969 when the United States placed in the mirror on the moon to measure the results showed that in 28years to the distance between the Earth and the moon increased 1 m, The United States and France the two scientists is the use of accurate time measurement to measurement, the distance between the change, This method of pulsed laser projection, and then to the mirror reflection back on the ground detector, a return of about 2.5 seconds, Constantly measuring return by the time the changes on the distance that can   change. Repeated measurements show that the earth and the moon because of the distance between the earth's surface tidal friction role annual increase of nearly 4 cm. Scientists believe the moon and under the influence of the Earth's gravitational tides produced, this tidal movement on the part of decentralized energy to the Earth's oceans, As a result of this energy - the loss of the campaign on the Moon system be affected, and this is moving away from the Earth's moon reasons. United States 2 geographers through Nautiloid Fossil study also found that the moon is moving away from Earth indeed. The two scientists observed several Nautilus existing fossil study found shellfish on the tree-ring wavy thread with the same performance, Thread at many points, though different width, but on every small wavy line growth in the 30 or so with the modern Lunar exactly the same as the number of days a month. Observed that the Nautilus, wavy lines of a long day, following a month long. Growth in this special two scientists to be greatly inspired, they observed the Nautilus ancient fossils surprised to find that the growth of every parrot the lines traced with the fossil's diminishing. And the age of the same line of Nautilus shell growth has to be fixed. Research shows that the modern Nautilus shell, the growth line is 30, the new generation of Oligocene Nautilus shell , the growth line is 26, Cretaceous Mesozoic is 22, 18 is Jurassic, Paleozoic Carboniferous is 15, Ordovician is nine, Concluded that 420 million years ago before the Ordovician, Paleozoic, and the moon around the Earth only nine days a week. Two geographers According to the Law of Universal Gravitation, such as physics theory, the moon and then calculated the distance between the Earth, Get a result, more than 400 million years ago, the Moon and the distance between the Earth is now only 43%. Scientists have also nearly 3000 to a record of pitting corrosion phenomenon on the calculation, of the findings fully consistent with the reasoning that the moon is gradually away from us.                              using gravitational& vortex force  the formula to calculate the moon from Earth:Cos а 1 Me = 6 × 10 ^ 24kg; month - the distance r = 38.4 × 10 ^ 7M Mgh = mv^2 / 2 V = at Moon average week: v-= 1 / π vsin ω td ω t = 2v / π Angular velocity difference: q = 29/30 = 1-1/30 V-= 2at / π; ω = 1 / T a = KGM ω/ r ^ 2 Mg = GMm / r ^ 2 111Daily the moon away from us:  h = 2GK ^ 2Mq / π ^2 r ^ 2= 2 × 6.67 × 10^-11 × 0.16 ×  6 × 10 ^ 24 × 29 / [38.4 × 10 ^ 7] ^ 2 × 3.14  ^ 2× 30= 8.51 × 10 ^- 5m From a year: 8.51 × 365 × 10 ^- 5 = 0.031m This is close the measured valueReference: “ mysterious vortex force  - gravity partner  ”Books Author: Zhuyonghuan Publisher: 21st Century Publishing House - China 2005-3With  Cavendish torsion balance experiment measuring gravity tangential component "and" physical communications 2002.9 " 

     

  • 03-26-2009 05:41 AM In reply to

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    I cannot find a reference at 21st Century Publishing House. I can find the publisher's Web site (link in previous sentence), but not a reference to the book mentioned.

    Can you provide a link?

    Signature
    The universe is not only stranger than we imagine, it's stranger than we CAN imagine. --- JBS Haldane
  • 03-26-2009 09:16 PM In reply to

    • zyh
    • Joined on 11-20-2008
    • Posts 19

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    hi  chipdatajeffB :

    www.sea3000.net/zhuyonghuan

     

  • 03-27-2009 02:15 AM In reply to

    Re: The Moon moving away from the Earth

    This appears to be your own filesystem located on a webhost server. Is that correct?

    Signature
    The universe is not only stranger than we imagine, it's stranger than we CAN imagine. --- JBS Haldane
Page 1 of 1 (14 items)
E-mail Address: Password:
Remember me?

Forgot your password » | Login help »

Not a member? Register » | Why join? »

My Profile

Copyright © 2009 Astronomy.com
Powered by Community Server (Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems