|
|

Astronomy forums are FREE. If you wish to participate you must
LOGIN | REGISTER.
Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
|
|
Sort Posts:
|
-
07-22-2008 06:34 PM
|
|
-
WannaB

- Joined on 04-30-2008
- Mindenmines, MO
- Posts 351
|
Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
Although it was discovered in 2005, the dwarf planet formerly known as the "eaterbunny" now has been formally named. Makemake now has it's own identity and I would like to take this opportunity to welcome Makemake to the neighborhood.
But, man, can you imagine what Pluto is going through right now? First you lose your spot at the adult's table and then a distant, no-name cousin that hardly anyone knew about comes waltzing in. Then, he gets a name and everyone starts making a fuss over him! Poor Pluto. I bet Pluto is hoping for a Nibiru in his near future.
Seriously, Makemake??? I get the reasoning behind the name, but the name doesn't really fit in. I mean, Mercury, Venus, Saturn, those are good star names, but Makemake? Oh well, guess I'll get used to it.
|
-
-
Red1530

- Joined on 09-28-2006
- New York State
- Posts 167
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
WannaB:
Seriously, Makemake??? I get the reasoning behind the name, but the name doesn't really fit in. I mean, Mercury, Venus, Saturn, those are good star names, but Makemake? Oh well, guess I'll get used to it.
I think you meant planet. Otherwise I agree with your assessment.
|
-
-
WannaB

- Joined on 04-30-2008
- Mindenmines, MO
- Posts 351
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
yep, sure did. Thanks for the correction!
|
-
-
chipdatajeffB

- Joined on 07-16-2002
- Dallas area, Texas
- Posts 7,035
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
Look at it this way: At the annual Solar System Ambassadors Banquet (sorry, JPL), the reps from Pluto have a (so far) very exclusive table ... and when New Horizons arrives in 2015 they will be the featured speakers!
|
-
-
-
Oliver Tunnah

- Joined on 12-05-2005
- Bristol UK
- Posts 690
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
Kratos Aurion: but now really MakeMake who thought of that name? Well at least Pluto has Xena
MakeMake was a Polynesian god. I.e. The people of Easter Island (See the link) believed in him.(Forgive me MakeMake if you're a female!)
Xena is now Eris aswell.
|
-
-
chuck81

- Joined on 02-09-2007
- SE Oklahoma
- Posts 426
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
I have to agree with WannaB. Makemake just doesn't seem like a planet name.
|
-
-
Oliver Tunnah

- Joined on 12-05-2005
- Bristol UK
- Posts 690
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
Yeah, I doubt that we have run out of Roman deities or even semi deities.
|
-
-
leo731

- Joined on 10-19-2005
- Posts 1,124
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
It could have been worse. The IAU just allowed an asteroid to be named Raphael Nadal.
Tennis anyone?
L
|
-
-
WannaB

- Joined on 04-30-2008
- Mindenmines, MO
- Posts 351
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
|
-
-
Oliver Tunnah

- Joined on 12-05-2005
- Bristol UK
- Posts 690
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
leo731:
It could have been worse. The IAU just allowed an asteroid to be named Raphael Nadal. That's either a joke or give me the news story!
|
-
-
leo731

- Joined on 10-19-2005
- Posts 1,124
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
No, it is really true! Nadal joins several other athletes who have been honored in this way. Lou Gehrig, Jessie Owens, and Lance Armstrong come to mind but there are several others. The discoverer of an asteroid is given rather wide latitude in what it shall be named.
Here's a link to the story:
http://sports.yahoo.com/ten/news?slug=reu-nadalasteroiddc&prov=reuters&type=lgns
L
|
-
-
Oliver Tunnah

- Joined on 12-05-2005
- Bristol UK
- Posts 690
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
I think the IAU must live on Nadal!
|
-
-
DaveMitsky

- Joined on 07-24-2001
- Pennsylvania, USA
- Posts 5,786
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
Many asteroids are named after people, including entertainers such as James Cagney, Cary Grant, Kirk Douglas, Grace Kelly, Johnny Carson, Meg Ryan, Louis Armstrong, Frank Sinatra, Elvis Presley, Buddy Holly, the four Beatles, Eric Clapton, Jimmy Page, Bruce Springsteen, and even groups such as Pink Floyd, Yes, and the Beegees. Others are fictional characters from literature and other sources, e.g., Madhatter, Doctorwatson, James Bond, and Mr. Spock.
http://cfa-www.harvard.edu/iau/lists/MPNames.html
Dave Mitsky
|
-
-
Kyle

- Joined on 06-07-2008
- Southern California, near L.A.
- Posts 164
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
There's plenty of good Roman god(ess) names out there. Take Bacchus, for example. The god of wine.
I know some people who would approve of that!
|
-
-
leo731

- Joined on 10-19-2005
- Posts 1,124
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
Kyle:Take Bacchus, for example. The god of wine.
Actually Bacchus is represented by the Q-type asteroid #2063.
Bottoms up,
L
|
-
-
Kratos Aurion

- Joined on 07-23-2008
- Posts 13
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
If not roman god’s then why not mythical monsters or creatures, like Bahamut, Shiva, Eefrit, Titain, Gnome, or medusa?
|
-
-
leo731

- Joined on 10-19-2005
- Posts 1,124
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
The IAU has shown that it is going to be rather particular in the naming of Planets, Dwarf Planets, and Plutoids but unless the chosen name for an asteroid is offensive it is pretty much fair game.
This leaves the discoverer with the following choices:
Suck up to the hand that fed you and name it after your parent institution.
Suck up to the nearest sports hero, famous actor or actress, or local/national politician so one can meet them and/or get some cash for further research.
Forever please your wife/husband by naming it after them.
Name it after some moldy old god of legend.
Speaking for myself it would be no contest and Asteroid Kimoanh would be gracing the heavens. 
L
|
-
-
Lover-of-the-stars21

- Joined on 07-03-2008
- Memphis, TN
- Posts 22
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
Just wanted to start out by saying, this is the longest post like everrrr - ok, anyway, what do you think that they could name something found, in the second, and smaller asteroid belt, that exists beyond neptune AND pluto ??? - anybody know anything about that, or am I in the dark or something? - sumbod-e help me =)
|
-
-
chipdatajeffB

- Joined on 07-16-2002
- Dallas area, Texas
- Posts 7,035
|
Re: Pluto in need of psychotherapy?
Here is a link to the IAU committee's published rules for naming of celestial objects. That might help!
Scroll down to Minor Planets to read about the rules for asteroids.
This is slightly out of date, as it doesn't mention the new nomenclature from last year's meeting.
|
|
|